Lastest article: "Good Guy" problem exists only in the mind
The Western Herald - "Good Guy" problem exists only in the mind
There’s an old adage about dating that I believe transcends all current generations. You can go back twenty years and read the conversations about dating, and not surprisingly, you will see the same arguments being discussed today. What I am talking about is the infamous statement of “why do women always date bad guys?” The Chicago Tribune printed an article on this situation in the Dec. 1 “Women’s News” section of its newspaper; the article proposed that women are attracted to the “bad boy” type of guy because they have a “rebel attitude” that women desire to tame. Okay, after we get past the obvious “um, Duane, why are you reading the Women’s News section of the Chicago Tribune?” we can continue to unpack this situation I consider to be a problem.
Now, I have been hearing and reading this type of explanation for a long time. The terminology changes over time, but the current terminology, at least in this article, considered the “cad” an individual that women attempt to win over, but then walk away from, frustrated, because they can never successfully tame him. What was interesting about this particular article is that it was absolutely nothing new. I swear I’ve read this article so many times over the years, that I’m shocked that newspapers and magazines even print them as if they’re breaking new ground.
Now, this usually leads into the other infamous commentary that comes from guys who claim that they are “good guys” but are continuously frustrated because women are seeking the “bad boy” kind of guy. Well, I have a further commentary on this idea, and that is the belief that I perceive most of these “good guys” really are not as good as they would like others to think they are. When I first arrived at WMU, there were a few guys I knew who were constantly whining about this particular phenomenon, and they would talk nonstop about how they were always finding themselves the “friend” to these women who were always dating the wrong guys, i.e. the bad guys. They used to complain that they were always there for these women, yet they were never given a single bit of attention. Thus, these women would go right back to the bad guys once they finished griping to these “good guys”.
Well, as someone who spent his younger years making some of the same complaints as these “good guys”, I think it is probably important to point out that I don’t believe them anymore. I don’t even believe myself (from before) anymore. You see, we all want to be seen as the good guy, but in reality we’re probably no better than the bad guys; we’re just not as obvious about it.
I personally think something different is going on here than the psychologists and analysts put forth in their reasoning. I don’t think it has to do with good or bad guys at all being the victors in these types of relationships; I think the victors are actually the ones that make themselves available. I honestly think it is as simple as that. These studies always quote women who complain about how good guys are so hard to find. Well, that may be the problem because the bad guy is always so much more in the spotlight trying to make contact than the good guy who seems to feel that somehow women are going to contact them.
Women are constantly complaining that the good guys are never around. Well, quite often they make these complaints to the good guys who happen to be their friends. I mean, I have probably ten close friends in my life. About eight of them are women. I’m in relationships with none of them. Why, you might ask? Well, several reasons. One, I feel they’re probably not interested in me because I buy into the whole “women want someone more exciting than boring me” idea. Also, I tend to believe that once they started dating me, they probably wouldn’t be as comfortable with me as they are now. I’m the easy guy, or the easy boyfriend without benefits, to be put more succinct. If I was smart, I would probably end most of these relationships and become more elusive, but I’m not, so I tend to maintain these types of friendships anyway.
The point is: I can make plenty of complaints about how many times I’ve had close female friends complain to me about really bad relationships they’ve been in with really bad guys, but it’s really my fault for being that person they can turn to. Quite often, I’ll help them through the bad situation they’ve experienced, and I’ll think I’m helping out a friend, but in reality what I’ve done is help them get over the last bad situation so that they can get into the next bad one much sooner than if they didn’t have me around to help them through the experience. And more often than not, they go back to the same guy that fits that “bad boy” mentality that becomes a big part of the complaint process.
Even with all that said, I do believe that there are some good guys who actually do exist. I tend to believe they are far harder to find, and rarely are they the ones complaining about being unable to find dates. I think most of them pull themselves out of the dating environment and focus on bettering themselves in hopes of one day finding the right person and then having something decent to bring to the plate. A few very fortunate ones may be in the right place at the right time, but I tend to believe that’s the Hollywood version more than reality. In this day and age, I tend to believe that if a woman is truly seeking the “good guy” in a sea of “bad guys” masquerading as “good guys”, perhaps they need to be a lot more careful about what they are seeking. When they find the right person, they may have to make the move themselves rather than wait for the next opportunist “bad guy” to intrude on their plans. If not, they can always find a good guy-friend to complain to about why they can’t seem to attract the right guy.
Duane Gundrum, the Western Herald opinion editor, is a Ph.D. student from Santa Monica, Calif., studying political science.
Stumble It!